Dockge vs Portainer: manage Compose like files, or like a platform?
Portainer is the incumbent GUI for Docker on a NAS. Dockge is the challenger with a philosophy: your Compose files stay plain files on disk, in a folder you own, editable by any tool, versionable in Git — the UI is just a friendly face on top. For Compose-first homelabs (which is what this site teaches), that philosophy fits suspiciously well. Here is the honest comparison and the migration that risks nothing.
Published Nov 18, 2026
The philosophical difference
Portainer treats Docker as a platform to administer: it keeps its own database of stacks, users and settings, and it can do things Compose cannot (Swarm, Kubernetes, fine-grained access control). Dockge — from the Uptime Kuma author — treats Docker as a folder of Compose projects: point it at a stacks directory and it lists what is there, whether or not Dockge created it. Delete Dockge tomorrow and your stacks keep running and your files remain exactly as readable as the day you wrote them. For a homelab whose source of truth is a folder of YAML (ours is — see the Compose Generator), that is not a limitation; it is the point.
Feature reality check
- Stacks: Dockge edits, deploys, restarts and shows combined logs for Compose projects, with a built-in terminal into containers. Portainer does all that plus image/container/network/volume management beyond Compose.
- Multi-host: Dockge agents let one UI manage several machines' stacks — covering most homelab fleets. Portainer's agent story is more mature and more enterprise.
- Users & permissions: Portainer wins outright — teams, roles, RBAC. Dockge is a single-admin tool wearing a login screen.
- Lock-in: Portainer stacks created in its editor live in Portainer's database (exportable, but a step). Dockge stacks are files, full stop.
- Resource appetite: Dockge is noticeably lighter — it is a focused tool and feels like it.
Deploy Dockge alongside Portainer (the zero-risk trial)
services:
dockge:
image: louislam/dockge:1
container_name: dockge
ports:
- "5001:5001"
volumes:
- /var/run/docker.sock:/var/run/docker.sock
- ./dockge/data:/app/data
- /volume1/docker:/volume1/docker # your stacks root, same path inside and out
environment:
- DOCKGE_STACKS_DIR=/volume1/docker
restart: unless-stopped
The one detail that matters: mount your stacks root at the same path inside the container as on the host, so the Compose files' relative paths and bind mounts resolve identically. Point DOCKGE_STACKS_DIR at it, open port 5001, and your existing projects appear — created by hand, by generator, by Portainer's file-based stacks — ready to manage. Run both UIs for a month; keep the one your hand reaches for.
Who should pick which
- Pick Dockge if: you are Compose-first, single-admin, and the words 'the files are the truth' make you nod. Also if Portainer's business-edition nudges grate.
- Stay on Portainer if: you manage containers beyond Compose, need user roles, or run Swarm/edge setups. Our Portainer guide remains fully valid — this is a preference fork, not an obituary.
- The hybrid most people land on: Dockge for daily stack work, Portainer kept installed for the occasional platform-level task — two small containers, no drama.
Official documentation and references
- Dockge on GitHub — official repository and documentation
- Portainer documentation — installation and stack management
- Portainer on GitHub — source code and releases
Frequently asked questions
Will Dockge break my existing Compose stacks?
No — it reads the same docker-compose.yml files from your stacks folder and operates them with Docker Compose itself. Stacks keep running independently of whether Dockge is up.
Can Dockge manage multiple servers?
Yes — Dockge agents on other hosts register with the main instance, so one UI covers a fleet of Compose machines. It is simpler than Portainer's equivalent and sufficient for homelab scale.
Does Dockge replace the Compose Generator?
They are complements: the generator creates a new stack's file with sane defaults; Dockge manages that file's life afterward. Generate, save into the stacks folder, deploy from Dockge.

