Home Assistant voice satellites compared: Voice PE vs Satellite1 vs ATOM Echo

A fully local voice assistant — Whisper listening, Piper speaking, nothing leaving your network — lives or dies on the little box across the room hearing you correctly. Three ESPHome satellites dominate the conversation: Home Assistant's own Voice Preview Edition, the FutureProofHomes Satellite1 kit, and M5Stack's tiny ATOM Echo. They cost about $69, about $70 in kit form (roughly $135 fully assembled), and about $13. Here is what that money actually buys.

Published Nov 18, 2026 · Last updated Nov 18, 2026

What a satellite actually does

The satellite is ears and a mouth, not a brain. It listens for a wake word on the device itself using microWakeWord, streams your command to Home Assistant, and plays back the reply. The thinking — speech-to-text with Whisper, intent parsing, text-to-speech with Piper — happens on your server, which is why the pipeline can be entirely local. Our Whisper + Piper local voice guide covers that server side end to end; this guide is about choosing the hardware at the edge. All three devices below run ESPHome and speak the Wyoming protocol to Home Assistant, so they are interchangeable in software — the differences are microphones, speakers, and finish.

The three, compared

Voice Preview EditionSatellite1ATOM Echo
MakerNabu Casa (Home Assistant)FutureProofHomesM5Stack
MicrophonesDual-mic array with audio DSPDual-mic array + XMOS far-field processorSingle PDM mic
Speaker3 W, tuned enclosure; 3.5 mm line-outLarger driver, best audio of the three; line-out0.5 W — replies only
On-device wake wordYes — microWakeWordYes — microWakeWordLimited — weakest of the three
Chip / firmwareESP32-S3, ESPHomeESP32-S3 + XMOS, ESPHomeESP32, ESPHome
FormFinished appliance, mute switch + dialKit — assembly and enclosure on youMatchbox-sized dev device
Typical price~$69~$70 kit / ~$135 assembled~$13

Voice Preview Edition — the plug-and-play pick

The Voice PE is what happens when the Home Assistant team designs the hardware they wish existed: a dual-microphone array with a dedicated audio processor, a speaker that was actually tuned, a rotary dial for volume, an LED ring that shows listening state, and — the detail that matters in bedrooms — a hardware mute switch that cuts the microphones electrically. Setup is minutes, the enclosure looks finished on a counter, and the 3.5 mm output lets it drive a real speaker later. For most rooms in most homes, this is simply the one to buy.

Satellite1 — the best ears, some assembly required

The Satellite1 is a community-designed kit built around an XMOS audio processor — dedicated far-field voice hardware of the kind the big smart speakers use. In a noisy kitchen or across a living room, its microphone performance is the best of the three, and its speaker is a step up too. The honest catch is in the word 'kit': you assemble it, flash it, and house it. There is no retail polish and support is a community, not a helpdesk. If you enjoy that side of the hobby, it is the enthusiast's pick and the strongest hardware here.

ATOM Echo — the $13 experiment

The ATOM Echo is a development device the size of a matchbox with a single microphone and a speaker you would describe as 'present'. Wake-word support on its older ESP32 is the weakest of the three, and across-room pickup is optimistic. And yet: at about $13 it is the cheapest way to find out whether local voice fits your life, it is a fine push-to-talk or desk-side satellite, and as a tinkering platform it punches far above its price. Just do not judge the whole concept by its audio.

Gear for this build

Prices are editorial and change often; buttons show live prices. Some links may earn a commission at no cost to you — see the disclosure page.

Which room, which satellite

Thinking about music? Let the satellite take the command and let real speakers do the playing. Music Assistant routes playback to the good audio gear you already own while the satellite handles the microphone work — the combination is much better than asking a 3 W puck to be a stereo.

Setup expectations

All three flash with ESPHome and connect through the Wyoming integration; the Voice PE is effectively plug-and-play, the other two assume you have flashed an ESP32 before. The satellite is only half the system — the server side is a pair of containers:

services:
  wyoming-whisper:
    image: rhasspy/wyoming-whisper
    command: --model tiny-int8 --language en
    ports: ["10300:10300"]
  wyoming-piper:
    image: rhasspy/wyoming-piper
    command: --voice en_US-lessac-medium
    ports: ["10200:10200"]

Faster hardware runs bigger Whisper models and cuts response latency noticeably; if replies feel sluggish, the fix is almost always server-side (model size, CPU) rather than a different satellite. The full walkthrough — pipeline setup, wake words, and tuning — is in the local voice guide.

Official documentation and references

Frequently asked questions

Does the wake word work without the internet?

Yes. On the Voice Preview Edition and the Satellite1, microWakeWord runs on the device itself: the satellite listens locally for 'Okay Nabu', 'Hey Jarvis' or 'Alexa', and only starts streaming audio to Home Assistant after it hears it. If your speech-to-text (Whisper) and text-to-speech (Piper) also run locally, the entire conversation stays on your network.

Which satellite is best for a bedroom?

The Voice Preview Edition. It has a physical mute switch that electrically disconnects the microphones, a dial for volume that works without opening an app, and a light ring that dims at night. The Satellite1 sounds better but is a hobbyist kit with more lights and presence; the ATOM Echo's speaker is too weak to be a pleasant alarm-clock voice.

Can a voice satellite replace my Echo or Google Home for music?

Not really, and it is better to know that up front. These are voice-control devices with small speakers — fine for replies, timers and announcements, underwhelming for music. Music Assistant can route real music to proper speakers in the same rooms, with the satellite acting as the microphone and controller. Treat the satellite as the ears and voice, not the stereo.

Is the Satellite1 hard to build?

It is a kit, not an appliance: you assemble the boards, flash ESPHome firmware, and fit an enclosure (printed or ordered). Nothing about it is difficult for someone comfortable flashing an ESP32, but there is no retail unboxing moment — if the words 'flash the firmware' make you tired, buy the Voice Preview Edition instead.

Do I need a satellite in every room?

Only in rooms where you actually want to talk to the house. Start with one in the kitchen or living room — the highest-traffic room — live with local voice for a few weeks, and expand once you know the pipeline feels fast enough on your server. The satellites are cheap to add later; an underpowered Whisper server is the thing to fix first.

Related guides